All articles

FinOps · · 5 min read

Why right-sizing AWS does not always cut your bill straight away

By Rushit Chandegara, Founder & CTO, InfraCloudEdge

A cost review finds servers running at 5% CPU, the team right-sizes them, and the next bill is about the same. This happens often, and the reason is usually a commitment bought months earlier.

How commitments are billed

A Savings Plan is a promise to spend a fixed amount per hour on compute for one or three years. AWS bills that amount every hour, whether your usage reaches it or not. Reserved Instances work the same way for a specific instance type or database.

So if your commitment covers $2 an hour and you shrink usage to $1.50 an hour, you still pay $2. The unused 50 cents is simply lost, until the commitment ends.

Which commitments are flexible

  • Compute Savings Plans apply across EC2 instance families, regions, Fargate and Lambda, so moving workloads around keeps them in use.
  • EC2 Instance Savings Plans are tied to one instance family in one region.
  • Reserved Instances for RDS, ElastiCache and other services are tied to their engine and instance type.
  • Savings Plans cannot be cancelled or resold. Standard EC2 Reserved Instances can be sold on the Reserved Instance Marketplace.

Plan cuts around expiry dates

  • List every active commitment with its end date, from Cost Explorer or the billing console.
  • Make the savings that do not fight a commitment now: unattached volumes, old snapshots, idle load balancers, logs kept forever, over-provisioned storage.
  • Schedule right-sizing of committed resources for just before each commitment ends.
  • Buy the next commitment against the new, smaller baseline, not the old one.

Read the bill carefully

Month-over-month comparisons also mislead when tools bill quarterly or annually, or when a large upfront payment lands in one month. Compare amortized costs over the same period before deciding a change did or did not work.

In a recent review for a SaaS client this split the findings in two: 22% saved straight away, and a larger cut scheduled for when reserved commitments expire.

More articles